Authors: Kozhevnikov V. V., Karavaev A. F., Zverev V. O.
Citation: Kozhevnikov V. V., Karavaev A. F., Zverev V. O. Status of Positive Legal Responsibility in the Terminology Base of General Theory of Law. Psychopedagogy in Law Enforcement. No 3(74). 2018. Pp. 88–94. DOI: 10.24411/1999-6241-2018-13016.
Для цитирования: Кожевников В. В., Караваев А. Ф., Зверев В. О. Статус позитивной юридической ответственности в понятийно-категориальном аппарате общей теории права // Психопедагогика в правоохранительных органах. 2018. № 3(74). С. 88–94. DOI: 10.24411/1999-6241-2018-13016.
Download article: Status of Positive Legal Responsibility in the Terminology Base of General Theory of Law
Abstract
Determining the relevance of the article by the importance of category of legal responsibility and notions (categories) condensing accumulated knowledge the authors focus on the category of positive legal responsibility as the legal subject’s awareness of his duty to the society, collective, social groups. Considering various interpretations of the category under study, arguments of its advocates determining the right of this phenomenon to exist the authors support the opponents of the positive legal responsibility. In particular, it is stressed that the latter fails to contain so-called state-legal component, and, therefore, cannot be included in the terminology base of general theory of law.
Keywords: legal responsibility, negative responsibility, positive responsibility, notions and categories, general theory of law, state-legal component.
References:
1. Vasilyev A.M.Legal Categories.Methodological Aspects of Developing the System of Theory of Law Categories.Works of the All-USSR Correspondence Institute.Vol.32.Moscow, 1973.Pp.80–85.(In Russ.)
2. Lyubashits V.Ya., Smolensky M.B., Shepelev V.I.State and Law Theory.Rostov, 2006.512 p.(In Russ.)
3. Nedbaylo P.E.System of Legal Guarantees of Applying Soviet Legal Norms.Jurisprudence. No.3, 1971.Pp.44–53.(In Russ.)
4. Astemirov Z.A.The Concept of Legal Responsibility.Soviet State and Law. No.6, 1979.Pp.59–67.(In Russ.)
5. Vlasov V.I., Vlasova G.B.State and Law Theory.Rostov-on-Don, 2011.331 p.(In Russ.)
6. Matuzov N.I.Socialist Democracy as the Unity of Rights, Duties and Responsibility.Soviet State and Law. No.11, 1987.Pp.135–143.(In Russ.)
7. Khachaturov R.L., Yagutin R.G.Legal Responsibility.Tolyatti, 1995.200 p.(In Russ.)
8. Strogovich M.S.The Essence of Legal Responsibility.Soviet State and Law. No.3, 1979.Pp.72–78.(In Russ.)
9. Images of Morality: Introduction to Ethics.Ed.by Obukhov V.L.St Petersburg, 1996.189 p.(In Russ.)
10. Tarkhov V.A.Responsibility under the Soviet Civil Law.Saratov, 1973.455 p.(In Russ.)
11. Voevodin L.D.Constitutional Rights and Duties of Soviet Citizens.Moscow, 1972.299 p.(In Russ.)
12. Razgildyaev B.T.Tasks of the Russian Criminal Law and their Implementation.Saratov, 1993.232 p.(In Russ.)
13. Nazarov B.L.On Legal Aspect of Positive Social Responsibility.Soviet State and Law. No.10, 1981.Pp.29–38.(In Russ.)
14. Matuzov N.I.Legal System and Person.Saratov, 1987.294 p.(In Russ.)
15. Mordovets A.S.Socially-Legal Mechanism of Providing Human and Citizen Rights.Saratov, 1996.286 p.(In Russ.)
16. Bazylev B.T.The Essence of Positive Legal Responsibility.Jurisprudence. No.4, 1979.Pp.40–46.(In Russ.)
17. Lipinsky D.A.The Problems of Legal Responsibility.Ed.by Khachaturov R.L.St Petersburg, 2004.387 p.(In Russ.)
18. Lipinsky D.A., Bessolitsyn A.G.On Distinguishing Measures of Protection and Measures of Legal Responsibility.Modern Law. No.4, 2013.Pp.12–16.(In Russ.)
19. Krasnov M.A.Legal Responsibility – an Integral Legal Phenomenon.Soviet State and Law. No.3, 1984.Pp.73–77.(In Russ.)
20. Fedorova V.G.The Concept of Legal Responsibility and its Regulative-Protective Nature.State and Law. No.9, 2007.Pp.87–92.(In Russ.)
21. Krotkova N.V.“Round Table”: “Freedom and Responsibility”.State and Law. No.3, 2007.Pp.109–127.(In Russ.)
22. Chukhvichev D.V.Individual Liberty and Legal Responsibility.State and Law. No.3, 2005.Pp.103–108.(In Russ.)
23. Bondarev A.S.Legal Responsibility is the Positive Property of the Subject of Law.Jurisprudence. No.1, 2008.Pp.133–144.(In Russ.)
24. Maksimov I.V.The Conception of Positive Administrative Responsibility in Theory and Practice.State and Law. No.8, 2006.Pp.29–37.(In Russ.)
25. Veklenko S.V.Criminal Responsibility: Theoretical Analysis of the Concept and Grounds for Arising.Problems of Counteracting Crime in Modern Times.Collected Materials.Omsk, 1999.Pp.37–43.(In Russ.)
26. Malein N.S.Offence: Concept, Reasons, Responsibility.Moscow, 1985.182 p.(In Russ.)
27. Khalfina R.O.General Study of Legal Relationship.Moscow, 1974.340 p.(In Russ.)
28. Maltsev V.V.Social Responsibility of an Individual, Criminal Law and Criminal Responsibility.Jurisprudence. No.6, 2000.Pp.152–169.(In Russ.)
29. Kuchinsky V.A.On the Concept of Legal Responsibility as a Fundamental Category in Jurisprudence.Legal Responsibility: Prob¬lems of Theory and Practice.Collected Materials.Ed.by Kuchinsky V.A., Sarkisova E.A.Minsk, 1996.Pp.4–19.(In Russ.)
30. P’yanov N.A.Consultations on State and Law Theory.Irkutsk, 2010.583 p.(In Russ.)
31. Shaburov A.S.Lawful Behaviour.Offence.Legal Responsibility.State and Law Theory.Ed.by Perevalov V.D.Moscow, 2007.Pp.259–274.(In Russ.)
32. Lyubashits V.Ya., Smolensky M.B., Shepelev V.I.Lawful Behaviour and Legal Responsibility.State and Law Theory.Rostov-on- Don, 2002.Pp.438–469.(In Russ.)
33. Lazarev V.V., Lipen’ S.V.State and Law Theory.Moscow, 2010.634 p.(In Russ.)
34. Chernogor N.N.On Theoretical Problems of Legal Responsibility.Journal of Russian Law. No.5, 2006.Pp.105–109.(In Russ.)
35. Leyst O.E.Sanctions and Responsibility under Soviet Law.Moscow, 1981.239 p.(In Russ.)
36. Marchenko M.N.Problems of Legal and Socially-Political Responsibility of Business.State and Law. No.11, 2007.Pp.5–11.(In Russ.)
37. General State and Law Theory.In two vol.Ed.by Marchenko M.N.vol 2.Theory of Law.Moscow, 1998.622 p.(In Russ.)
38. Marchenko M.N.Problems of General State and Law Theory.In two vol.vol 2.Law.Moscow, 2008.656 p.(In Russ.)
39. Leyst O.E.Methodological Problems of Legal Responsibility.Problems of State and Law Theory.Ed.by Marchenko M.N.Mos¬cow, 2002.Pp.626–655.(In Russ.)
40. Shaburov A.S.Political and Legal Aspects of Social Responsibility of an Individual.Extended Abstract of the Doctor of Sciences Dissertation (Law).Yekaterinburg, 1992.34 p.(In Russ.)
41. Smirnov V.G.Functions of Soviet Criminal Law.Leningrad, 1965.188 p.(In Russ.)
42. Elionsky V.A.Criminal Punishment and Cultivating Individual Positive Responsibility.Ryazan, 1979.84 p.(In Russ.)
43. Lipinsky D.A., Shishkin A.G.Subjective Law and Legal Duty as the Means of Positive Legal Responsibility.State and Law. No.10, 2014.Pp.5–14.(In Russ.)
2. 44. Gabrelyan E.V.Juridical State Theory: Theoretical Grounds and Conclusions.State and Law. No.6, 2017.Pp.52–59.(In Russ.)
Submitted: 25.12.2017